Description

** UPDATES Sept 2019
Koetsu Blue Lace with Diamond Cantilever is the BOMB. Unambiguously the best cartridge I've ever heard. The diamond cantilever raises detail, speed and dynamics of Koetsu to a next level, without pulling it towards analytical. In fact, this change actually allows MORE of the famous Koetsu musicality to pour through the speakers. Added in March of this year. Mounted on the FR64S (this arm is now clearly superior to the Graham Phantom Supreme for Koetsus). I've also switched my SUT to the Choir Audio unit based on Hashimoto HM-7. My EAR MC-3 and Koetsu SUT (pictured here atop the VAC) also sound great with the Blue Lace, but the Hashimoto sounds HUGE with lifelike dynamics. Another change is rolling tubes in the VAC phono: 1 pair Mazda 12ax7 chrome plates (my favorite), 1 pair RCA black plates 12ax7, 1 pair Mullard reissue 12ax7 - this results in a tonal balance similar to the stock tubes, but with enhanced detail, 3D imaging, and bass impact. If it weren't for my need to closely track the stock tonal balance (because that works well with my system), I'd have all 6 Mazda chromes in there - and the Mullard pair is there because it's warm enough to counter the Mazda's top end (otherwise, it's a serviceable but not stellar tube). Stock tubes were VAC's selected PentaLabs (Chinese) 12ax7. The latest system pic shows a Rogue RP-9 preamp on the bottom rack shelf, but I still use the ARC REF 6 as my primary preamp. I'm also back to the Shelter Harmony on a Clearaudio Universal 12" for my 2nd arm, which I try to mix in to save hours on Koetsu - I haven't been very successful at this, however! As good as the Harmony/Universal combo is (for a while I was going back & forth between this and the non-Diamond Koetsu stone bodies), the Blue Lace just takes everything to another level. 

** Updates Feb 2018
I have upgraded literally EVERYTHING since July 2017. I kept with the same general system composition; in many cases simply moving to newer model years and/or the next model(s) up. I did change from all Rogue Audio electronics to VAC & ARC for phono stage & preamp -- yes, I have to admit that was the right move for me to finally make. I've stuck with the Rogue Apollo amps, but bought the new "Dark" upgraded versions. And also bought a big-boy CMS Maxxum rack -- sayonara, Lovan!! I think I've kept like 3 power cords, a pair of AQ Kilimanjaro, and a pair of AQ Wild interconnects. Everything else is brand new. 

** Updates Sept/Oct 2016
Added a few updated photos, and posted a more detailed comment on recent upgrades. My original upgrade plans, as enumerated below, were formulated in 2010/2011. I've finally logged updates to each of these items. The core Tannoy/Koetsu/Rogue blend has always remained in place -- because it sounds awesome! I've also had my beloved Koetsu Onyx Platinum recently broken (RIP to my girlfriend), and bought a new Coralstone to console myself.

Mazda silver-plate 12ax7 have been put EVERYWHERE. A friend introduced me to this tube in 2015, and I absolutely love it. BIG upgrade over the usual suspects: Telefunken (smooth & ribbed), Mullard long-plates, RCA long black plates, RCA 3-mica 5751, GE 5751 "silver clips", etc.

I've fallen a bit sucker to the cable industry, and have been moving up in the Audioquest line (mostly silver) when I can find the right ones used. 

My headphone system has also gone crazy in the last 2 years: Stax SR-009, Stax L700, Head-amp BHSE (stocked with the ample vintage British/Mullard or Holland/Amperex EL34 on hand), Schiit Yggdrasil. Also have a KGSShv Carbon, Balanced-hev90 clone, KGST, KGSShv x2 etc. But the BHSE is the best. I also have a SR-007 Mk I, but strongly prefer the SR-009 and L700.

My (now very old) upgrade plans:

1) Tannoy Canterbury SE; their size is better suited to my room; the 96dB efficiency is also very appealing 
** UPDATE: Did this October 2012 - A VERY good move in the end, though I must admit it's very frustrating to re-tune & adapt everything for a new speaker, even one from the same line as its predecessor (Tannoy Kensington SE). The Kensington needed a boost in bass energy and some relaxation up top. The Canterbury SE needs some help coaxing sparkle/energy up top. The Canterburys simply sound HUGE, and I love it. 

2) Phono stage...perhaps a CineMag blue step-up to feed into the VAC Ren III's phono. Or, drop the VAC (as good as it is) and start from scratch. Perhaps a Hagerman Trumpet w/ CineMag blue or Artemis Labs? 
** UPDATE: Finally settled on a Rogue Ares in late 2014, after the THIRD TIME buying this phono stage, lol. Its latest revision is superb when paired with: Mazda Silver-plate 12AX7, Sylvania 1950s Black Plate 12BH7 OR Mazda Silver-plate 6189, and Bob's Devices 1131 SUT (each of these makes a BIG difference). Finally, this combo yields notably better sound than the built-in phono of the VAC Renaissance III that I loved so much. 

3) Table: Either a SOTA Cosmos or a Clearaudio Innovation Wood Compact (leaning heavily towards the SOTA due to past experiences) 
** UPDATE: Got the Clearaudio Innovation, obviously, in Spring 2014. With Graham Phantom II Supreme tonearm. Great table/arm, but not without their imperfections. And expensive. VERY expensive. Overall I'm mostly happy with this table rig, though. Added the Clearaudio ring clamp and reference weight late 2014 (way too expensive, but nice).

All setup in an old loft apartment in a commercial district with NO RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORS!! The best time to crank the system up is midnight-5am - there's nobody within a mile! Solid, over-built late 1800s construction. No laundry hookups, no oven, no cable - but NO complaints from me for the overall benefits :)
** UPDATE: Still the same hookup :)
Read more...

Room Details

Dimensions: 21’ × 14’  Medium
Ceiling: 10’


Components Toggle details

    • Tannoy Canterbury GR
    Big Tannoys; totally rad speakers!!
    • VAC Master 300 Musicblocs
    Transformative, transcendent amplifiers. Largest single-component improvement I've heard in my life. Absolutely blows the 200iQ's away.
    • VAC Master
    Line-Stage. I never felt 100% about this preamp when paired with the Signature 200iQ's. But now paired with the Master 300 monos - oh yeah, 100% world class baby! Stunning!
    • VAC Signature 200iQ
    Stunning sound quality
    • VAC Renaissance Phono SE
    Stunningly natural, lifelike sound
    • Clearaudio Master Innovation
    Badass Turntable
    • Critical Mass Systems MAXXUM
    Crazy expensive rack, but it works as advertised, and earns its keep while looking awesome!
    • Audio Research REF 6
    Very clean, clear sounding Preamp
    • Koetsu Coralstone Diamond
    Amazing, stunning, beautiful cartridge. The Onyx Platinum is now my 2nd favorite.
    • Koetsu Onyx Platinum
    Pure. F___ing. Magic. In the midrange. Treble and bass quality are not as good as say an Ortofon Windfeld, but they're still quite good. And the Ortofon midrange is just awful by comparison to any Koetsu.
    Recently rebuilt in Japan; good as new again!
    • Koetsu Jade Platinum
    Sounds almost exactly like the Onyx Platinum, but slightly less warm and slightly more air on top. Very, very close. I keep this one in reserve.
    • Ortofon MC A90
    • Rogue Audio Apollo Dark
    Very good, very powerful tube amps.
    • Bob's Devices Sky 40
    Step-up Transformer; great match for the Koetsu Platinums.
    • AudioQuest Niagara 7000
    w/ NRG 1000 PC
    • Rogue Audio Ares Magnum
    Great phono stage, notably better than the non-Magnum Ares. Even with the Cinemag 1254 Blue SUT built-in, I still added an outboard SUT: Bob's Devices Cinemag Sky 40. Also upgraded the hell out of the mediocre stock tubes: Mazda 12AX7 chrome plates, Sylvania 12BH7 black plates. Superb match with Koetsu cartridges this.
    • Rogue Audio Hera II
    Upgraded to Hera II status. Fabulous sound, BUT NOT dead quiet (in conflict with the product description page's boast). It's a high-gain tube preamp so there is some noise floor if you have sensitivity amps and speakers like I do. I can deal with it because the sound quality beyond that is so great. I liked it better than the VAC Renaissance III line stage.
    • Clearaudio Innovation Wood
    Excellent table. A good clamping scheme is essential for any high-end vinyl rig -- and Clearaudio's clamps are excellent.
    • Graham Engineering Phantom Supreme
    The Graham Phantom Supreme arm is GREAT with Koetsu
    • Head-amp Blue Hawaii SE (BHSE)
    Exotic, beautiful, and amazing sounding electrostatic headphone amplifier for the top Stax headphones.
    • Stax SR-009
    The best headphones in the world. Requires electrostatic headphone amp.
    • Stax L700
    The best of the Lambda series. Not as good as the 009, but an exceedingly enjoyable headphone. I prefer this L700 to the SR-007 Mk I (a.k.a. Omega 2)
    • Audioquest (All analog cabling)
    WEL LP phono, WEL LP 0.5m RCA (for SUT), Fire RCA, Fire XLR, Wild Blue Yonder XLR, Wind XLR, Sky RCA, Sky XLR, Niagara RCA, Mont Blanc, Kilimanjaro (x2).
    • Sonic Frontiers Phono 1 SE+
    Fully upgraded by Parts Connexion. Awesome phono stage that's sadly becoming rarer and more unheard of by the day. Think I'll be retiring from the last few years' phono stage madness with this unit. Edit 2016: Whoops, guess I liked the Rogue Ares w/ 1131 SUT better after all. And the new Ares Magnum is even more better.
    • Phison Audio A2.120SE
    Sweet solid state power. 120 Watts/ch.
    • Phison A2.120 SE
    Solid State Class AB stereo amp, 120 Watts/ch, MSRP $12K. Sounds WAY sweeter than I ever expected a SS Class AB amp could sound, plus with killer bass! It's become one of my favorite components over the past year, and competes earnestly with my $30K VAC 200iQ monos!

Comments 147

i have the Kensngton SE and i am trying to find that perfect balance of interconnect and speaker cable. are you still using the Audioquest and what has been your experience. i currently have Siltech in my system.

dsholl1

Great Mulveling! very happy for you mate! - no worries about the late reply, glad you went down the tannoy rogue route - instead of the ares, i got the Decware ZP3 - similarly priced but It only takes MM - but it is indeed a mind blowing pieces of work! (it takeS my SoundSmith Boheme well) - yes, you are right indeed - the stock rogue tubes are terrible, i've just begun rolling the driver tube on the integrated with a NOS 5814 RCA Blackplate - hell of a difference! need to swap out the 12ax7 and the rest of the 12UA7, wonder if the cronus will take the KT120:))

thegoodarcher

Owner
Thanks guys!

Hoa,
Those are GIK Acoustics Tri-Traps in the corners and GIK 242 panels on the front wall. Excellent acoustic effectiveness, extremely reasonably priced, and though not premium in build quality they don't look terrible. Since I bought mine they now offer premium cloths/colors. I might check and see if they have a good match to the Tannoy's tweed grills...though the plain off-white does blend in to the walls.

Yeah, the Kensington SE are magic once you get the right gear behind them - but therein lies a challenge, as despite their musicality they are deceivingly revealing/resolving and every tube/component change will be heard LOUD AND CLEAR. They've actually made my gear habit worse this past 2.5 years.

Nice that you have Tannoys AND Harbeths. Lots of British audio WIN in your home!

mulveling

I like it!

mapman

Hello Mike,
What is the brand of the bass traps that you used behind your system? I just got a pair of Tannoy Kensington SE and LOVE them!!! Thinking of doing a little room treatment to get the best out of my system. Thanks in advance.
Hoa

jaytea

Owner
System edited: Much experimenting with tube rolling. Haven't yet run into an RCA black plate - of 12AX7, 5751, and 12BH7 - that I don't like...and certain variants in particular are just lovely. Also liking the Mullard long-plate 12AX7 and Tung-Sol 12BH7. Not a fan of any 12AU7 yet. Ditched the EH KT90 for the new-ish KT120. NICE improvement there. The KT90 were just too forward up top. KT120 is nice and balanced; silky smooth from mids through treble, and with even more powerful bass. Still haven't convinced myself that the 6H30-DR are worth trying (@ $200 a pop times 8).

mulveling

Owner
Thegoodarcher,
Man, I haven't checked this thread in a while - sorry for the way delayed reply. I used an Atlas (not even magnum) before the Apollos, and I know the Cronus you've got sounds really sweet.

I've had the Ares for more than a few months, and it actually took me a while to warm up to it. The problem is that I'd been using a Sonic Frontiers Phono 1 - clearly better than even the GCPH - but it was adding a touch of warmth to my system. That was kind of compensating for the crappy stock EH 12AX7 small signal-tubes I'd been using in my Apollos.

I finally put some nice NOS tubes in 12AX7 and 12AU7 positions on the Apollos (ended up with 12BH7A in place of the 12AU7). Then, I put some RCA 12AU7 cleartops in the Ares. The Ares still ONLY has EH 12AX7 (soon to be rectified), but already it's clearly the most resolving stage I've had yet. Killer bass and dynamics. Very clean & neutral; I'm sure I can tune it further by finally swapping those 12AX7s. The SF is running a quad super nice JAN Amperex 7308, and it's still getting beat. Loving that Ares - and I must remember to never cheap out on small-signal tube rolling in the future!

mulveling

Owner
System edited: Updated system. Hera preamp is off to Rogue for upgrading to version II+ status. In the meantime I'm left with a little SS headphone amp (with preamp outputs) - despite being a real nice headamp it SUCKS compared to the Hera. Really was starting to take that thing for granted, and it should be even better when it gets back. Next...is it even worth it to gamble some $1.6K for an octet of 6H30-DR supertubes in this preamp?

mulveling

Hello There,
I am new here, your set up looks amazing:) i have the modest Cronus Titan Integrated "Magnum Version" with 90w/pc (with KT 90 Tubes).

I am too contemplating on the "Rogue Ares" Phono Stage, i had a PS Audio GCPH up to yesterday, since i am in Malaysia, it might take sometimes for the Ares to get here - i'd appreciate any feedback regarding this, since it will take sometime to reach our local distributor.

Equally, i didnt quite feel the stealth, now lets go all rogue..

Cheers!

P/S : I am eyeing on the Tannoy Stirling SE ( have you tried the super tweeter?)

thegoodarcher

Very nice system and room, I'd love to hear it!

stuartson

Wonderful system...love to hear that!

artk

Owner
System edited: Added my reel-to-reel tape deck to system. I LOVE the sound of the damned thing but it's a bit of a PITA. Sometimes the left channel cuts in/out intermittently - it think it may be happening after the unit is fully warmed up. Or perhaps it's somewhat tape-dependent...or maybe both! The RCA jacks are also WAY TOO CLOSE together. I don't have any RCA cables with barrels skinny enough to fit well. Finally hooked it up again, a couple nights ago - first time with the Apollos. It's definitely worth putting up with (for now), for the sound and the needledrop music I've got on Maxell tapes. I've been looking forward to every night I'm at home, so I can go through more LPs and tapes!

mulveling

Owner
Thanks Jerico!

I've been very impressed with the GCPH. It's dead neutral, resolving, about as smooth as I've heard from Solid-State gear. It's better than my Benz PP-1 (at least on Ortofon carts - I used to have a Glider L2, hence the Benz), for less money. The XLR outputs are a nice plus with a preamp like the Athena/Hera. At $700 new - how can you argue with that?

The only reason I haven't bought this GCPH from my dealer, is that I'm impatiently anticipating the soon-to-be-released Rogue Ares phono stage ($2K MSRP). It's going to be an AD797 step-up plus a tube MM stage of four 12AT7 tubes. It would be nice to have an all-Rogue system (I'll be asking for fancy metal feet to match to Hera/Apollo, heh). I've previously tried the Rogue Stealth and loved the voicing, but it wasn't as resolving nor as quiet as the PP-1. If the Ares fixes that, then it'll be perfect for me. Though I do wish it would have XLR outputs, which it won't.

Still, if the Ares doesn't beat the GCPH noticeably, then the GCPH will stay! I certainly can't complain about the sound I'm getting now. Of course that won't stop me from trying to improve it further, as this affliction dictates. Next, I'd like to look at an Ortofon Winfeld cart upgrade - which may dictate a lower mass arm, too.

mulveling

That's a beautiful looking setup - and I'm envious of the lack-of-residential neighbor aspect!

I also have a GCPH and have been very happy with it (picked it up new for $700 as well - so VERY happy given the discount).

jerico

Owner
System edited: Big update - Apollo monoblocks have arrived, and the Atlas will be gone soon. Also using a loaner PS Audio GCPH (XLR outputs into the Hera) in place of the Benz PP-1, with 50-ohm loading. The Apollo/Hera/Kensington combination is freaking blowing my mind.

mulveling

Way to go Mike! Sounds like your close to where you want to get. Congrats on the amps, and good luck in your hunt for the phonostage.

tom_hankins

Owner
Thanks for the comments, guys!

Well here's where the "ever evolving" comes in...

I've had the Rogue Hera for a month now. It's been a modest revelation for me. Significantly better resolution and micro-dynamics, along with a BIG increase in soundstage depth, a slight increase in width, and a more neutral/natural tone (as opposed to hitting all AROUND the bulls-eye with different variants of 6sn7 in the 99). Absolutely worth the cost of entry, and in fact I feel I got a GREAT deal on mine.

Unfortunately, now I've had a taste of higher-end and it's like blood in the water. After auditioning a different amp and phono stage in my system, it's clear those two components now represent weaknesses.

Amp:
The system's "macro-dynamics" didn't receive a commensurate bump-up with the introduction of the Hera. An audition of my friend's Stereo 90 Magnum easily showed why - I actually lack enough power for high dynamic range recordings (classical). This was a somewhat surprising to me - I now admit I underestimated my power requirements. That and the 90 Magnum displayed a bit more finesse and articulation too. I decided it's time to move on from The Atlas (GREAT amp for the money), so I now have a pair of Apollo monoblocks on order from my dealer :)

Phono Stage:
I auditioned my dealer's PS Audio GCPH in place of my Benz PP-1 (current T9 version), both using 100 ohm loading on my Ortofon Kontrapunkt "c". The PP-1 was more resolving that other stages I'd previously tried (Aragon 47K, Rogue Stealth, Dynavector P75), but at the expense of a slightly nasty spike/peak/resonance somewhere in the treble. I always assumed that was a side effect of its resolving power - that it was just revealing something in my cartridge or TT setup. Once again, it turns out my assumption was probably wrong. The GCPH is wonderfully smooth over the WHOLE range, no treble peak, and every bit as resolving. In fact, the bass is ever-so-slightly more punchy and taut. The GCPH midrange doesn't have the touch of added warmth of the PP-1, and it's just a tiny bit less 3D, but overall the GCPH is wonderfully liquid and musical, tonally dead neutral, and more enjoyable if only for the lack of that treble aberration. I should also note that I was running AQ Cheetah XLR cables from the GCPH, while the PP-1 uses AQ Jaguar RCA. So, this is not completely fair ground, but the treble problem is too much to be explained by the cables alone IMO. I also might get a Rogue Ares phono stage (soon to be released tube/SS hybrid) for audition, so the winner between that and the GCPH will likely be my next phono stage.

Cables:
Well now this has begun too. I really really like the solid silver I've heard - so smooth AND resolving, with NONE of the brightness that some complain about with silver. I got a pair of AQ Cheetah XLRs that will connect the Hera to the Apollos, when they arrive. I've got an incoming pair of Sky RCAs in anticipation of the Ares phono stage. I've ordered a LeoPard phono cable. My pair of Mont Blanc speaker cables will have to do for now (they don't suck), after some minor re-termination surgery. The Mont Blancs are smoother and more 3D than the LAT silverfuse cables I've repeatedly tried to "downgrade" to (to recoup some money from the Mont Blancs). A little down the line I may look into bi-wiring with VERY short (3-4ft) pairs of KE-4 and Gibraltar.

Speakers:
The Kensngton SEs are here to stay. They've SIGNIFICANTLY enhanced my enjoyment of music in the year since I purchased them. The magic there hasn't yet begun to wear off (for gear, a year is a LONG time with me), though I'm continually shocked at how resolving they are of ANY component (and cable) changes in the system. It's time to get the "right" system behind them.

Mike

mulveling

MIke,
Hope the preamp gets there quick and works out as good as you hope! (sure it will) Great system.

tom_hankins

Would love to see more photos of your space.

gsm18439

Congrats on your system. I,too, just bought Kensingtons (not the SE) and cannot say enough about them. Oh so musical! I also have tubes and an ortofon cartridge. ENJOY!

aronsss

Old or new, you've got to love those Tannoy's! Congrats on a beautiful system, Tannoys and tubes were meant for eack other, as in the 40's, when the DC's were first developed, there wasn't anyhing else. Enjoy.

Regards,
Dan

islandmandan

Very nice system. I agree that classic Mullard tubes really awaken the Rogue gear...truly a must. Enjoy.

chadlesko

Showing 126 - 147 of 147 posts