Yes, I replaced the noisey stock Raytheons and tried both the 5692 RCA "Red Base" tubes as well as an NOS Russian 6SN7, both of which were huge upgrades over the stock raytheon tubes in terms of lowering the distortion. Marconi 6SN7s are also pretty good and I tried those. I preferred the NOS Russian tubes.
Bare in mind I'm not talking an audible noise like a hiss or a hum. I am talking about the noise floor. I lowered the noise of The Dude considerably, but it is substantially noisier and became ultimately less musical than the system I have now.
Not saying the Dude is bad... it's probably one of THE BEST preamps on the market. It's just not as good as what I'm using now.
The front end I am using is a Pro-DAC and preamp. So I have a bit-perfect signal being sent to my amp. I can set up a similar system for around $6k. (roughly the price of the Dude + a decent DAC)... which is basically what I did. Sold my DAC and The Dude and was able to set up this system for myself. There are lower-end options (around $2500) that also trounce the Dude. It's not even a contest.
I've been telling people for ages that if you remove the noise the music will be there. Tubes or Solid state, it doesn't matter. Remove the noise and more music will be present.