Components Toggle details

    • Revel Ultima2 Salon2
    A full 7.4 setup of Salon2 speakers with JL Audio Fathom F113 subwoofers. All seven surround speakers and subwoofers in gloss Black.
    • SME Model 20/2
    Uh, it's an SME... ;)
    • SME Series IV.Vi
    Included in the 20/2 performance package
    • Lyra Titan I
    Uh, it's a Lyra Titan... ;)
    • Sutherland PhD
    Phono PreAmp
    • Denon AVP-A1HDCI
    You've tried the rest, now try the best... ;)
    • Ayre Acoustics MX-R Monoblocks
    In custom ordered black
    • Denon DVD-5910
    Multichannel Universal Player and DVD-Video Player in black
    • Bryston PowerPac 300 SST (3 of them)
    In black, used for surround channels, and the center channel
    • Sim2 C3X 1080
    1080P 3-chip DarkChip4 DLP projector.
    • JL Audio Fathom F113 (4 of them)
    Four in the recommended setup for deeper frequency extension (Harman Research paper by Todd Welti)
    • Stewart Filmscreen Luxus Model A w/ Studiotek G3 Screen Microperf X2
    128.5" diagonal 16:9 screen. Viewing distance ratio to the screen is ~1.4.
    • Sony Playstation 3
    Blu-Ray player, video game machine, etc
    • Microsoft Xbox360 & HD-DVD add-on
    HD-DVD player and video game machine
    • Jeff Kalman Self Built Gaming Rig
    - Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 overclocked to 3.2 GHz - Thermalright Ultra-120 Extreme (CPU Cooling) - Patriot Extreme Performance PC2-8500 2GB RAM (2 * 1024 MB) - 2 * BFG Tech OC2 8800GTX in SLI - eVGA nForce 680i SLI (122-CK-NF68-T1) - 2 * Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 500 GB in RAID 1 configuration - Creative SOUND BLASTER X-Fi Fatal1ty - ENERMAX Galaxy 850 Watt - Thermaltake Armor Series Case - Digi002 Rack Unit w/ ProTools
    • RPG Diffusor Systems Inc. Skylines
    High Profile, to break up ceiling reflections
    • RPG Diffusor Systems Inc. Absorbers
    Absorption panels, to break up sidewall reflections, slap echo and other issues
    • RPG Diffusor Systems Inc. BAD ARCs
    Both diffusion and absorption for the sidewall 1st reflection points - i.e. 4 of them)
    • RPG Diffusor Systems Inc. BAD Panels
    Custom sized panels for front left and right ceiling 1st order reflection points.
    • Rives Audio Level 2 Acoustical Room Design
    This is a Rives Audio designed room.
    • Tascam DV-RA1000HD
    For making DVD-A backups of my LPs
    • Salon2 with Lexicon MAX EQ engaged, 1/6th and 1/12th octave measurement
    Lexicon set to Max EQ and Sub 30 PEQ engaged as well. Very nice frequency response... The sound is finally crystal clear!!!
    • W/P8 & Salon2 Overlay 1/6th Octave
    @ 80dB
    • W/P8 & Salon2 Overlay 1/12th Octave
    @ 80dB

Comments 166

Showing all comments by shadorne.

View all comments

I set up all seven Salon2s and the four Fathom F113s and the sound is earthshaking.

Wow. You were serious. That is some accurate deep bass you must have there. I bet Master and Commander opening scenes are impressive.

shadorne

I might even have to add two or four more Salon2s to complete the entire design (one pair for each row of seats for a total of 9 or 11 speakers depending on if I do two or three rows).

Wow. You are so thorough. I am so impressed. How about a sub under each seat? ;-) (just kidding)

Or perhaps the Buttkicker ?

shadorne

Good to see you still making progress. If you like percussion then a fun DVD is Black Eyed Peas "Live from Sydney to Vegas" - the Sydney concert is good sound quality - some seriously good drumming from Keith Harris and very little of the usual audio compression you normally get on music DVD's.

shadorne

Thanks for posting more pics. Your new and impressive speakers look awesome. Glad to hear the WP8's completely solved your recessed mid range issues. I see you are planning to get Wilson surrounds too...the whole thing will be extreme all out; so of course I'll keep checking for updates. Thanks for sharing - I really appreciate those who take time to post many pics. Seeing a real system kind of adds a dimension or weight to your forum comments and posts. After all, many of us have heard many speakers in demos and can hence pronounce authoritatively on this or that ...but serious setups like yours (with extensive acoustic treatements) distinguish a serious listener/fanatic from a casual poster/gear collector who simply pushes their current favorite component (usually the last one purchased).

shadorne

Funny you should mention Alan Parsons. One of the albums where I had more issues than others on certain songs was Pink Floyd's "Dark Side of the Moon

Yes, but you need to be aware that even Pink Floyd had different views about how "muddied" or loud the vocals should sound compared to the rest of the mix...so in this particular case it may be intentional and the 802D's were just telling the truth (i.e. what Alan Parson's/PF intended at the time).

See this Dark Side Interview

shadorne

It was often nasally in that range and the vocals sunken behind the music

Well I agree that a forward mid range is much more desirable than a recessed mid. However, Alan Parsons uses the Nautilus 802 or the predecessor of the 802D in his studio so it can't be all that bad....perhaps more a matter of personal preference as you suggest!

I definitely enjoyed reading your reply and all about your system and the evolution. I look forward to future updates once you get the WP 8's. thx

shadorne

No RT60 or waterfalls to share. I was really wondering how they would differ given all your bass trapping and extensive rear wall treatments?

BTW I was surpised about your 802D comments (lack of mid range/male vocals). I agree that the mid range is the critical piece in a speaker...all to often it is deliberately recessed by most manufacturers (so speakers have a bass and treble sizzle). Usually it is down to a dispersion problem....too narrow a dispersion in the mid range which gives a total sound field that is mid range weak. Other problems can be mid range compression - although I doubt that the 802 has this problem. Actually I was beginning to wonder if you might have overdone the dispersion/absorption in the mid range - you certainly have extensive side wall and ceiling treatments, as well as a carpet....all of which will really tone down the mid range! Have you considered this possibility?

shadorne

Wow. One helluva room. I bet that sounds absolutely awesome! The extensive treatment at the rear is impressive. Do you have any before and after reverberation time plots?

shadorne