Jfrech,
I'm very familiar with those two recordings and listen to them on a regular basis, they are very good choices for comparing formats. I agree with you, I don't find one of these formats inherently superior to the other. Depending on component, system development and other variables there's much overlap in sound quality. You have an excellent system comprised of superb components so your listening impressions aren't surprising to me. Congratulations and continue to enjoy the beauty of music with both sources.
Charles,