I generally prefer the analog source, but I have more CDs than LPs so I listen to whatever the music is on. I am always amazed by how good analog sounds, even on my very 'low-end' table. I would love to upgrade the turntable, but alas I have two kids in expensive day care....
I really like the Ah! player. Changing the tubes from stock to some Siemans 7308s was very pleasing. I am almost ready to swap tubes again for something different.